19.7% of 3,882 votes
Columbus, you don’t need little blue boxes to be impressed. What you need is quality pieces at a reasonable price delivered in a professional manner. And that’s why Diamond Cellar is Columbus’ favorite jewelry store for yet another year. People of Columbus, frost yourselves!
Multiple locations | diamondcellar.com
2: Tiffany & Co 13.9%
3: Worthington Jewelers 13.4%