42.5% of 9,556 votes
When Cuban cuisine meets a diner set-up, you get the magic that is Starliner Diner. The restaurant has been serving Southwestern and American fare with everything from huevos rancheros to tamales. Starliner’s goal has been to provide a change in pace from chain restaurants when it comes to eating out, and with 24 years of dining under their belt, it seems they’ve truly struck gold in Hilliard.
4121 Main St. | starlinerdiner.com
2: Beer Barrel Pizza 22.5%
3: Legacy Smoke House 11.7%