J. Gumbo’s

37.2% of 6,295 votes

Feeling a bit under the weather? Looking for something to warm your soul? Look no further because J. Gumbo is your safe haven. Their cajun/creole menu offers flavorful dishes that are packed with spices, various meats, and plenty of vegetables. Dishes like the Drunken Chicken showcase how they are able to play with the spicy-ness of sauces while the Gumbo served atop white rice is what put them on the map.

Multiple locations | jgumbos.com

2: Gallo’s Kitchen & Bar 24.9%

3: Creole Kitchen 22.4%

Watershed Distillery

Watershed’s spirits are the real deal. Never satisfied to rest on past successes, Columbus’ favorite distillers are always pushing boundaries. Furthering their already stellar reputation, Watershed’s bar and restaurant in Grandview sets the standard for service and creativity on the local dining scene. It’s more than just great hooch!

18.8% of 3,943 votes

2: Woodlands 18.1%

3: Byrnes 14.9%

Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams

33.3% of 13,985 votes

Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams is no longer a Columbus secret, but it’s still a Columbus staple. The ice creams here are carefully made with fresh ingredients and offer tons of different flavors like Brambleberry Crisp and Brown Butter Almond Brittle. There’s no question that when it comes to ice cream, Jeni does it best.

Multiple locations | jenis.com 

2:  Graeter’s Ice Cream 30.1%

3: Whit’s 8.4%