Mikey’s Late Night Slice
15.8% of 13,957 votes
With the amount of Mikey’s Late Night Slices popping up around Columbus, it’s not a shock to see them secure another victory in the ColumBEST for best traditional pizza. The Late Night Slice craze is real! It’s the perfect spot to grab a quick bite to eat with the pizza by the slice option, or you and your friends can split the Dysfunctional Family option which is a full pizza, a few PBRs, and a few shots of liquor to keep things extra exciting.
Multiple locations | latenightslice.com
2: Masseys 8.8%
3: Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza 8.5%