42.3% of the votes
Cheryl’s started with the basic cutout cookie that stemmed from the owner’s Midwestern roots. She added a basic buttercream made with only four ingredients – and here we are today. If you’re the lucky person who gets the birthday box of cookies, let us just say, we envy you.
Multiple locations | cheryls.com
2. Insomnia 29.1%
3. Fox in the Snow 28.6%