Best Neighborhood Restaurant- Polaris/Westerville

1. CARFAGNA’S KITCHEN
36.8% of the votes

Carfagna’s handmade kitchen honors the grandparents who founded the eatery in 1937, using the best, freshest ingredients available. The authentic dishes are a win for anyone looking for delicious handmade pastas, pizzas, dishes, and sauces.

2025 Polaris Parkway | carfagnaskitchen.com

2. Asterisk Supper Club 32.8%
3. Kitchen Social 30.4%