Iconic Ohio Valley pizzeria closes Hilliard location

While DiCarlo’s Pizza opened a new Columbus-area location in Westerville last month, the popular Steubenville-based pizzeria has shut down another.

According to the voicemail greeting of the pizzeria’s Hillard storefront, which was located at 4142 Main St., the eatery is now closed. 

“Our Hilliard location is now closed. Please continue to place all online orders at our website or come visit us at 91 E. 5th Ave., Italian Village, Columbus, Ohio,” the recording said. “We value our customers and apologize  for this inconvenience.”

BROUGHT TO YOU BY

A DiCarlo’s employee confirmed the closure as well.

Famous for adding cheese to its pizzas only after they’ve left the oven, DiCarlo’s now operate two Columbus-area stores: its newly-opened Westerville storefront, which is operated by a franchisee, and its Italian Village location, which opened last year and is operated by the DiCarlo family.

Want to read more? Check out our print publication, (614) Magazine. Learn where you can find a free copy of our new July issue here!

BROUGHT TO YOU BY