This popular 20 year old central Ohio pizza shop is up for sale

A cherished spot for crispy, Columbus-style pizza, meatball subs, and spaghetti dinners is up for sale after 20 years.

According to the real estate listing, the owners of Sugar Bears Pizza, Lisa & Connie Beatty, are ready for retirement. They’ve owned the Lancaster pizza shop for two decades, and after being in the pizza business since their family started one in 1947, they’re ready to retire.

BROUGHT TO YOU BY

“One of Lancaster’s favorite pizza restaurants is FOR SALE,” says the listing. “Sugar Bears is a tradition in Lancaster (and far beyond) with a 4.6 Google rating, 4.5 TripAdvisor rating, and a loyal customer base.”

For $799,900, the buyer gets two parcels with 1,800+ SF dine-in restaurant and a drive-thru window (that’s not currently being used), plus parking for 12+ vehicles, business and trade name, recipes, well-maintained equipment, and more. 

The realtor specifically asks to not inquire and ask the Beatty sisters about the sale – if you’re interested in buying the pizza shop, check out the listing here.

Want to read more? Check out our print publications, (614) Magazine and Stock & Barrel. Learn where you can find free copies of our newest issues here!

BROUGHT TO YOU BY