75-year-old local pizzeria chain abruptly closes a Central Ohio restaurant due to ‘underperformance’

If you’re planning on ordering some pizza in that weird limbo after Christmas and before New Year’s, there’s one less place to do that now.

Hilliard residents were surprised to hear a voicemail stating, “Massey’s Pizza Hilliard is permanently closed,” when they tried to place an order last week. 

BROUGHT TO YOU BY

Massey’s Pizza Hilliard, located at 5068 Cemetery Rd., closed abruptly without notice on social media or in a press release. This location offered the iconic, all-you-can-eat pizza buffet. 

A Massey’s Pizza’s spokesperson said, “While we are sorry to leave the Hilliard area. We decided to close this underperforming store to tighten up the bottom line heading into the new year. This location has never met our expectations and unfortunately was on the chopping block. We definitely enjoyed being part of the community.”

Want to read more? Check out our print publications, (614) Magazine and Stock & Barrel. Learn where you can find free copies of our newest issues here!

BROUGHT TO YOU BY