National publication creates extensive list of highest-ranked pizzas in Columbus
The best part of pizza is that even when it’s bad, it’s good. You know what I mean?
Fortunately though, we don’t even have to worry about “bad pizza” in Columbus. With a plethora of family pizzerias serving crispy Columbus-style pies, or gourmet restaurants slinging thin, wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizzas, there’s something for everyone here, and it’s bound to be delicious. That being said though, there are some places that are better than others.
Stacker, a national publication that often analyzes data from Yelp, compiled a list of the 29 best pizzerias in Columbus, based on diner feedback. “Data is as of March 29, 2024. Businesses were selected using Yelp’s ranking system, which calculates an adjusted rating value that takes into account the number of ratings as well as the rating score itself. Only restaurants with at least 25 reviews were considered,” said Stacker.
Let’s dig right in!
#29 Roosters
Multiple Locations
#28 Natalie’s Music Hall & Kitchen
945 King Ave.
#27 Cafe Bistro
4000 Worth Ave.
#26 Emilio’s Pizza
574 Georgesville Rd.
#25 Northstar Cafe
Multiple Locations
#24 Forno Kitchen + Bar
721 N. High St.
#23 Meister’s Bar
1168 Chamber’s Rd.
#22 OH Pizza & Wings
Multiple Locations
#21 Ange’s Pizza
Multiple Locations
#20 GoreMade Pizza
936 N. 4th St.
#19 Susie’s Sub Shop
3739 Karl Rd.
#18 The Pizza House
747 East Lincoln Ave.
#17 Harvest Pizzeria
Multiple Locations
#16 Dewey’s Pizza
Multiple Locations
#15 Rubino’s Pizza
2643 E. Main St.
#14 Paulie Gee’s Short North
1195 N. High St.
#13 JT’s Pizza & Pub
2390 West Dublin Granville Rd.
BROUGHT TO YOU BY
#12 Aracri Pizzeria
51 East Gay St.
#11 Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders
4926 Morse Rd.
#10 Dante’s Pizza
3586 Indianola Ave.
#9 Papa Giorgio’s
5216 Bethel Center Mall
#8 Mama Mimi’s Take N Bake
Multiple Locations
#7 Oldfield’s North Fourth Tavern
1571 N. 4th St.
#6 East Coast Pizzeria
5060 N. High St.
#5 Martha’s Fusion Kitchen
3331 Maize Rd.
#4 Yogi’s Hoagie’s
1274 Morse Rd.
#3 Terita’s Pizza
3905 Cleveland Ave.
#2 Lois Mann’s Restaurant
1904 S. High St.
#1 Fibonacci’s Pizzeria
3055 Indianola Ave.
Want to read more? Check out our print publications, (614) Magazine and Stock & Barrel. Learn where you can find free copies of our newest issues here!
BROUGHT TO YOU BY
